Not sure what to look for yet? Try The Coffee Colony All time favorites in sample sizes. Each bag is 1/5lb, the perfect amount for you to find the favorite cup of your own.
Jamaican Me Crazy Flavored Coffee
For more than 40 years, Jamaican Me Crazy Flavored Coffee has been The Coffee Colony's best selling coffee and a favorite among customers throughout Northeast Ohio and beyond. This signature blend combines the rich taste of premium 100% Arabica coffee with smooth notes of caramel, rum, and vanilla for a truly memorable cup.
Expertly roasted to a medium roast profile, this flavored coffee delivers a bold, full bodied experience with a wonderfully aromatic finish. The sweet, creamy flavor notes create a perfectly balanced cup that's enjoyable any time of day and especially delicious when brewed as espresso.
Sourced from carefully selected African coffee beans and hand picked for quality, Jamaican Me Crazy continues to be one of our most requested coffees year after year. Whether you're discovering it for the first time or stocking up on a longtime favorite, it's easy to see why this blend has earned its reputation as a customer favorite.
---------------------
Caramel Nut Scotchie Flavored Coffee
1/5 Caramel Nut Scotchie is a caramel nut sundae in a cup! This is a decadent flavored coffee that blends the rich sweetness of buttery caramel with warm notes of butterscotch and roasted nuts. This smooth, aromatic coffee delivers a velvety body with hints of golden toffee, creamy caramel, and a subtle nutty finish that lingers pleasantly on the palate. The balanced flavor profile creates a comforting, dessert-inspired cup that's indulgent without being overly sweet. Perfect for enjoying black or with a splash of cream, Caramel Nut Scotchie Coffee brings the cozy taste of a homemade treat to every sip.
---------------------
Southern Pecan Flavored Coffee
A Coffee Colony best seller, this medium roast coffee offers a smooth, comforting flavor inspired by the rich taste of roasted pecans. This well-balanced medium roast combines the mellow sweetness of freshly toasted pecans with subtle notes of buttery nuttiness and a gentle caramel finish. The medium roast profile allows the coffee's natural flavors to shine while delivering a smooth body, low bitterness, and a pleasant aroma that fills the room. Perfect for morning enjoyment or an afternoon treat, Southern Pecan coffee provides a warm, Southern-inspired experience in every cup.
---------------------
Chocolate Cinnamon Hazelnut Flavored Coffee
Bold, warm, and decadently smooth, our Chocolate Cinnamon Hazelnut Flavored Coffee brings together three classic flavors in perfect harmony. Crafted from premium Arabica coffee beans, this rich blend layers deep chocolate with toasted hazelnut and a comforting hint of cinnamon spice. The result is a cozy, dessert-inspired cup with complexity, warmth, and a satisfying nutty finish.
---------------------
Highlander Grogg Flavored Coffee
Escape to a warm, cozy retreat with our Highlander Grogg Flavored Coffee, a customer favorite known for its rich, buttery sweetness and smooth, comforting finish. This indulgent blend combines premium Arabica coffee with the classic flavors of buttery caramel, creamy butterscotch, warm vanilla, and a hint of rum-inspired essence (non-alcoholic), creating a deliciously aromatic cup that's perfect for any time of day.
